Recent retail headlines in the business news lately been particularly negative: bankruptcies, store closings and financial woes. Yet research from Deloitte demonstrates that the industry is indeed experiencing significant disruption — but that it’s not just negative disruption.
During the #RIC17 panel titled Escaping The Trap Of Convention: How To Rethink Retail And Regain The Customer, Kasey Lobaugh, Chief Retail Innovation Officer at Deloitte and moderator of the panel, reported that holiday 2016 was the strongest retail holiday season since 2011.
“Over the holiday, we found both online and brick-and-mortar grew by roughly $12 billion,” said Lobaugh. “The growth rate was different: online grew 12% and stores grew 2.3%. But the growth is still there.”
These apparent contradictions have the industry scratching its head, wondering what’s really going on. According to the panel, the answer to how retailers should rethink competition to regain the customer boils down to just that: the customer.
The panelists included:
- Rose Hamilton, Chief Digital Officer, The Vitamin Shoppe (former)
- Chau Banks, Executive Vice President, Chief Information Officer and Channel Integration, New York & Company
- Jason Morris, Vice President of Retail Technology, Walmart
The Evolution Of Omnichannel
It’s the retail buzzword to end all buzzwords: omnichannel. But no buzzword is more important than the customer.
It’s no longer about being omnichannel, it’s about being able to turn your customer into an omni-customer, according to Banks.
“You have to have thorough inventory visibility and be able to look at it across any selling point,” said Banks. “That’s common and a goal we’re all working towards. I don’t think we’ll ever be 100% there. For me, the struggle every day is how do we get omni-traffic to our stores and continue to build that. It’s looking at the big picture and understanding when is the best time to reach that customer with that product, and to be able to help that customer be a repeat customer. That’s what it has become for us: Making her an omni-customer. It’s not about the way we sell it, but about the way she buys it.”
The Shift In Competition
Lobaugh noted that there has been a fundamental change in the industry around the proliferation of new sources of competition.
“I use this analogy sometimes: If you’re out hunting with a friend and you see a bear, you don’t have to be faster than the bear, you have to be faster than your buddy. In some cases, the bear is the customer, and your buddy is the competitor,” he said.
“This idea about competition and who we compete with is a missed component in the industry,” Lobaugh added. “The fact is that we’re shifting market share from the concentrated bigger companies to a really long tail of very small controlled competitors. The race we’re running is very different.”
The panelists agreed that a little competition is healthy.
“We’re a single brand product company so essentially we compete with ourselves,” said New York & Co.’s Banks. “It’s about how quickly you can evolve — not just with product, but with the destination point for the customer. We recently started selling on Amazon because that is another channel for us. But we only compete with Amazon as a product company — we’re leveraging their technology and fulfillment channel as an opportunity for us. It’s healthy.”
Walmart’s Morris also noted that when retailers compete, the customer wins because everyone gives their 110%. “We’re trying to optimize the products the people want; we try to provide them to them in a way that they see value in them — whether it’s price or personalization,” he said. “Then, it’s about getting the product to the customer. So, whoever can optimize those three pillars of retail best will win. But others will win also, because winning is not exclusive.”
The moral of the story is, focus on the customer and steer away from all these conventional wisdom words, because they won’t tell you how to win in the marketplace.
“Never bring a knife to a gun fight,” said Lobaugh. “Conventional wisdom doesn’t understand what fight you’re fighting.”