Study: Industry-Wide Efforts Will be Needed to Build on Sustainability Progress

Enhancing sustainability in retail and related industries is extremely complex — and that’s putting it mildly. Data from The Sustainability EDIT 2021 from marketplace intelligence platform EDITED reveals both progress and problems, including greenwashing and concerns about offering products that are simultaneously sustainable, affordable for consumers and profitable for retailers.

Fashion in particular is faced by the conundrum of shoppers simultaneously demanding exciting new options and greater environmental stewardship. “The fashion industry is built on a cycle of overproduction and overconsumption,” said Kayla Marci, Market Analyst at EDITED in an interview with Retail TouchPoints. “As the climate crisis accelerates, retailers have been overhauling their products and processes to help reduce their environmental impact. Retailers are backing recycled materials to help cut emissions and minimize waste, positioning them as a more responsible alternative than producing new products, positively impacting the value chain and creating an attractive point of sale for consumers wanting to shop more sustainably.”

Indeed, while the number of styles made with recycled materials and components has increased 503% since 2019, there is still much work to be done on this front. Only 34% of products sold in the U.S. are made with 100% recycled materials. Additionally, Marci noted that using recycled material is just one of multiple tools for achieving sustainability goals.

For example, retailers also should be looking at ways to keep items out of landfills after shoppers are done with them, and more broadly they and their suppliers should be making efforts to reduce post-consumer waste.


“Going beyond recycled polyester, brands have been experimenting with post-consumer waste products to upcycle into new items, such as repurposed food waste, ocean plastics and debris,” said Marci. “Brands can also look to their own waste to incorporate in new products, such as material offcuts.”

Understand Your Audience to Find the Right Approach to Sustainability

Many retailers also struggle with the higher costs often associated with sustainable products, and worry that they will face challenges in passing along those costs to the end consumer. For example, sustainable menswear was priced 12% higher than traditional menswear on average and womenswear was priced 4% higher — and not every retailer will have a sustainable shopper base willing to pay more for a better product.

There are negative perceptions on both ends of the scale,” said Marci. “If sustainable goods are too affordable, customers suspect greenwashing. If products are too expensive, retailers can risk alienating lower-income consumers’ opportunity to buy into conscious products, reaffirming the image that sustainable fashion is for elitists.”

The solution, as with so many other challenges in retail, is understanding your customers. In particular, retailers “need to find what their consumer is willing to pay, break down what makes a product sustainable and clearly communicate how pricing factors in,” said Marci.

Retailers with a customer base that skews younger have a leg up: more than half (54%) of Gen Z consumers would pay over 10% more for a sustainably made product.

Sustainability Can Synergize with Inclusivity

Retailers also shouldn’t look at sustainability as its own unique effort — meeting the challenge overlaps with many other projects important to shoppers. For instance, inclusivity and sustainability can actually go hand in hand. Average consumers’ apparel sizes don’t offer as many sustainable options as smaller sizes, which reduces shoppers’ options when they try to make sustainable wardrobe choices. Only 9% of currently available plus-size jeans use alternatives to conventional cotton, and just 3% of styles are described as “recycled.”

Above all, being size-inclusive is being sustainable,” said Marci. “Our bodies inevitably change throughout our lifetime. There are opportunities for retailers to make products that wear well and evolve with these changes, optimizing slow fashion that’s made to last. As well, more retailers are investing in repair and alteration services, extending product longevity.”

Simply getting inclusivity right goes a long way as well. Marci noted that Ganni’s partnership with plus-size retailer 11 Honoré has enabled better-fitting apparel for a variety of styles and body types, which ensures everyone can find something that looks good and fits well, ultimately reducing waste.

Every Retailer Can Benefit From Improved Sustainability

Sustainability and fashion are often brought up in tandem, but that doesn’t mean other verticals can’t benefit from bigger investments in sustainability. For instance, homeware was an area where sustainability grew in a big way during 2021:

  • The number of products described as recycled or recyclable experienced a 77% rise year-over-year;
  • Products containing organic or Better Cotton Initiative (BCI)-certified fibers grew 167% year-over-year;
  • Rattan furnishings and accessories likewise increased 167% year-over-year; and
  • Products made with bamboo grew 242% year-over-year.

Hot categories like activewear also are seeing a rise in sustainability. The amount of performance wear items with sustainable keywords rose 52% year-over-year in fall 2021, while sustainable athleisure jumped 76%. Recycled polyester has played a large role in this shift, though Marci noted that it isn’t a permanent solution.

Recycled and renewable are only pieces of the larger sustainability puzzle. Companies looking to get serious about their sustainability efforts need to look at the entire supply chain, including post-consumer, and find ways to help the planet that also appeal to shoppers.

“Despite more retailers making an effort to operate more responsibly, the bottom line is overproduction is still a glaring issue,” said Marci. “It’s here where the lines between improving processes and greenwashing often get blurred. Fashion brands are using less impactful materials and are ramping up their sustainable manifestos — yet on the other side of a global pandemic, there is still more newness than ever before. In addition to introducing more recycled materials, retailers also need to clearly communicate how they’re improving their impact in line with broader, global environmental goals that benefit both people and the planet.”

Featured Event

Join the retail community as we come together for three days of strategic sessions, meaningful off-site networking events and interactive learning experiences.



Access The Media Kit


Access Our Editorial Calendar

If you are downloading this on behalf of a client, please provide the company name and website information below: