In an era when online shopping is not just a convenience but a way of life, a new menace is plaguing consumers and retailers alike: porch piracy. Our recent research reveals that over a third of U.S. online shoppers have fallen victim to this form of theft within the past year. The situation is particularly dire for younger generations, with over half of Gen Z consumers reporting that they have experienced porch piracy in the last 12 months.
The Scope of the Problem
Porch piracy refers to the theft of packages delivered to consumers’ doorsteps, and the numbers are alarming. According to HubBox’s research, victims of porch piracy suffered an average of six thefts in the last year, with the total value of stolen goods per person exceeding $300. For many, this is not just an inconvenience but a significant financial loss – half of the respondents claimed they were left out of pocket after the theft.
The frequency and impact of these thefts underscore a broader issue within the ecommerce ecosystem. As more people opt for the convenience of online shopping, the ease with which packages can be stolen has become a significant risk. The problem is exacerbated during peak shopping periods like Black Friday and Prime Day, when the sheer volume of deliveries provides ample opportunity for porch pirates to strike. Our poll found 80% of victims experienced theft during these high-traffic shopping events, making them prime targets for thieves.
The Impact on Retailers
While the immediate loss is borne by the consumers, retailers are far from unaffected. The responsibility often falls on them to resolve the situation, whether that means replacing the stolen item or issuing a refund. This not only cuts into profit margins but also risks damaging the brand’s reputation; 46% of porch piracy victims said the experience negatively impacted their relationship with the retailer. Nearly two-fifths of shoppers were deterred from purchasing from the same brand again after their packages were stolen, illustrating the long-term impact on customer loyalty.
Advertisement
Retailers are caught in a difficult position. They must decide whether to absorb the cost of the lost goods as a goodwill gesture or refuse compensation, which could lead to negative reviews and customer attrition. In either scenario, the retailer loses, either financially or reputationally. This has led to a growing demand for more secure delivery options as customers seek ways to protect themselves from theft.
Urban Areas at Higher Risk
The problem of porch piracy is not uniform across the United States. Urban areas in particular are hotspots for this type of crime. Our research indicates that 47% of consumers living in large towns and cities have experienced theft of online packages. The dense population and high delivery traffic in these areas make them attractive targets for thieves. This trend suggests that as urbanization expands, so too will the prevalence of porch piracy.
The demographic data is also revealing. Gen Z and millennials, often the demographics that order the most online, are the most frequent victims, with these groups experiencing an average of eight and seven instances of theft per year, respectively. This could be due to a combination of factors, including higher rates of online shopping among younger consumers and a greater likelihood of living in urban settings where porch piracy is more common.
The Search for Solutions
As the frequency and severity of porch piracy incidents grow, so too does the demand for more secure delivery options. Our poll shows that over half of American shoppers would now prefer to use shipping to a local Access Point to avoid the risk of theft. This shift in consumer preference is not just a reaction to the current epidemic of porch piracy, but also a proactive measure to protect their purchases.
Using local pickup points provides secure alternatives to home delivery. By allowing customers to collect their packages from local Access Point locations, like UPS Stores or CVS, these services reduce the risk of theft and offer added convenience. Access Points are typically open for extended hours, including weekends, and some are available 24/7, making it easier for consumers to retrieve their packages at their convenience.
For retailers, offering alternative delivery options like these can be a way to mitigate the impact of porch piracy on their bottom line and customer relationships. It also presents an opportunity to enhance the customer experience by providing more flexible and reliable fulfilment options, as well as reaching new customers, such as shift or night workers, for whom home delivery isn’t convenient due to their working hours. And with the cost of fulfilling orders to shoppers’ homes rising, it also presents a cost-effective and margin-saving alternative, especially during peak trading periods like Black Friday when retailers are already offering discounts, making margins all the tighter.
The Broader Implications
Porch piracy is more than just a nuisance; it reflects a broader challenge in the evolving landscape of ecommerce. As online shopping becomes the norm, ensuring the security of deliveries has become a critical concern for both consumers and retailers. The rise of porch piracy undermines trust in the ecommerce process, making it imperative for all stakeholders to address the issue more urgently.
Retailers must continue to listen to customer demands and innovate around their delivery options accordingly, offering secure alternatives, like a local Access Point, that protect customers’ purchases while giving them peace of mind that their packages will be safeguarded. As our data suggests, the trend toward alternative delivery methods is gaining traction, signaling a potential shift in how online orders are fulfilled in the future.
In conclusion, the growing problem of porch piracy is a challenge that cannot be ignored. With significant financial losses for consumers and reputational risks for retailers, the need for secure delivery solutions is more pressing than ever. By embracing innovative alternatives like local pickup delivery, the ecommerce industry can take a crucial step toward combating this pervasive issue and restoring consumer confidence in online shopping.
Sam Jarvis is the CEO and Founder of HubBox, a market leader in ecommerce software for local pickup. HubBox’s software enables online retailers to offer local pickup options to their shoppers at the point of checkout, integrating seamlessly with the major ecommerce platforms including Shopify, Magento, Salesforce and BigCommerce. HubBox works with over 1,000 retailers and partners with the world’s top carriers like UPS and DPD, supporting their mission to offer retailers and shoppers better choice and deliver improved margins and environmental credentials through delivery consolidation.
