As the retail landscape becomes increasingly competitive, ensuring that pricing feels fair and transparent has never been more vital. In an age when shoppers are armed with more information and higher expectations, understanding how pricing is perceived isn’t just helpful – it’s critical.
HappyOrNot’s October 2024 report, Retail’s Biggest CX Trends in 2024, sheds light on a growing issue for retailers: customer dissatisfaction with pricing. According to the findings, dissatisfaction with pricing has surged to become the leading source of complaints, outstripping concerns such as stock availability, customer service and checkout processes.
Alarmingly, this dissatisfaction intensifies as the day progresses, peaking at 4 p.m. – a time when stores are typically at their busiest. Even more concerning is that this trend is exacerbated on Saturdays, the busiest shopping day of the week. Left unaddressed, this growing dissatisfaction with prices poses a great threat to retailers in harming customer trust, diminishing repeat business and eroding long-term profitability.
Nonetheless, there is a silver lining. Within this challenge lies a significant opportunity. Proactively addressing pricing allows brands to not only resolve a critical pain point but also to establish a competitive edge in an increasingly crowded market. The rewards of such efforts are substantial: by tackling this issue head-on, retailers can transform a potential liability into a powerful lever for growth and loyalty.
Advertisement
What Drives Price Perception Variability?
The perception of pricing is influenced by shopping patterns. Customers visiting early in the day are often routine visitors with a clear purpose. They visit stores with specific items in mind, aiming to complete their purchases before moving on to their daily tasks. This focused approach, combined with quieter shopping windows, makes them more attuned to promotions and sales. The calm atmosphere reduces frustration and encourages patience, creating a ‘clean slate / fresh start’ effect, where customers are less sensitive to pricing early in the day, having yet to encounter other expenses.
By contrast, afternoon shoppers – many of whom are browsing sporadically – often encounter busier stores, heightened stress levels and cognitive fatigue. These factors, coupled with a lack of familiarity with the store or its pricing, can amplify price sensitivity. Fatigue from a hectic day can make minor inconveniences – like unclear pricing – feel much worse. The culmination of these conditions is a sharp rise in pricing dissatisfaction around 4 p.m.
The consequences of unchecked pricing dissatisfaction extend far beyond unhappy customers; they can undermine revenue and loyalty. Dissatisfied customers may leave empty-handed, or worse, decide not to return. For retailers, this is both a warning and an opportunity. Strategies such as clear pricing, targeted discounts and real-time feedback offer powerful tools for transforming a critical challenge into a competitive advantage.
Transparency is key. Clear pricing and communication are essential tools to build trust. Crucially, a recent study shows 71% of shoppers reported it is more important to trust brands they buy from today than in the past, with this need highest amongst Gen Z. Similarly, 58% report worry about misinformation. Shoppers want straightforward explanations about costs, discounts and promotions. Investing in detailed signage and ensuring staff are trained to explain prices can make a big difference – especially during weekends, when price scrutiny is highest. Avoid surprises at checkout by maintaining transparency throughout the customer journey.
Dynamic pricing systems or price-matching policies must not be underestimated in managing price perception. A recent report shows that retailers adopting such pricing strategies can boost profits by 5% to 10%, while driving sustainable revenue growth and enhancing customers’ perception of value.
By adjusting prices in real time based on demand, competition or traffic, retailers can maintain a competitive edge and reassure customers they’re getting a fair deal, particularly during peak periods. Another strategy is offering strategic discounts during high-dissatisfaction times, such as late afternoons or Saturdays, which can help shift the narrative around pricing. Targeted promotions, like ‘happy hour’ pricing at 4 p.m., provide value when it’s needed most and can turn frustration into satisfaction.
Similarly, loyalty programs can mitigate pricing concerns by offering exclusive deals and added value to frequent shoppers. These initiatives build long-term relationships and reduce sensitivity to occasional pricing fluctuations. Real-time feedback is something to make use of – collecting and acting on real-time feedback allows retailers to address pricing concerns as they arise. Tools like digital surveys or feedback kiosks can pinpoint issues, enabling managers to make swift adjustments. This immediate response fosters trust and keeps customers engaged.
Looking Ahead
Managing customer price perception is more than just a short-term fix – it’s a cornerstone of building a loyal customer base. Transparent pricing, thoughtful promotions and real-time responsiveness can transform a common frustration into competitive advantage. Retailers that prioritize fair pricing and effective communication will not only retain their customers but improve their bottom line.
For more information, or to download the full report, please visit: https://www.happy-or-not.com/en/insights/resources/retails-biggest-cx-trends-2024-report
Tim Waterton is the Chief Revenue Officer at HappyOrNot, the company globally recognized for their smiley-faced feedback terminals, used by over 4,000 brands in more than 135 countries. With over 20 years of experience leading and building revenue teams at global technology companies, Waterton has a wealth of expertise in driving operational efficiency in service-based businesses and using data to understand the impact of the customer experience. Headquartered in Finland, with an office in the U.S. and a global reseller network, HappyOrNot has provided over 1.5 billion consumer responses for thousands of clients across the globe, including some of the world’s most successful brands such as Google, Aramark, Heathrow Airport, Amazon, Rocket Stores, Knox Community Hospital and more.