Ping Identity’s Cayla Curtis on Retailers Building Consumer Trust in AI Shopping Agents: The RetailTouchPoints.com Q&A

Published: November 17, 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Consumers are open to AI shopping support, but most still want firm approval limits and greater control before trusting autonomous purchasing.
  • Retailers that prioritize transparency, permission controls and identity safeguards will be better positioned to build trust in agentic commerce.

AI shopping assistants keep getting smarter, but consumers aren’t ready to hand over the keys. New research from Ping Identity finds that 56% of consumers are most comfortable using AI for support and recommendations, such as comparing products or narrowing choices. Only 31% would let AI make lower-stakes decisions on its own, like selecting products.

Hesitation runs deepest around money and identity. Consumers set an average limit of $200 for routine purchases an AI agent can make without approval, though 42% cap that limit at $100 or less and 22% won’t trust AI with any financial transaction. Trust in the companies behind these experiences is also slipping. Only 12% of consumers fully trust organizations to manage their identity data, down from 17% last year, and 71% worry that an AI agent acting for them could misrepresent their personality, ethics or values. For retailers, that means autonomy has to be earned, not assumed.

These gaps matter for retailers investing in agentic commerce, where AI agents don’t just suggest purchases but complete them. Retail TouchPoints spoke with Cayla Curtis, Senior Director, Product Management for CIAM and Consumer Agents at Ping Identity, to explain where consumers draw the line on autonomous AI shopping agents, how retailers can handle data access and AI disclosure without adding friction, and what they can do now to prepare for regulation around AI, identity and data.

RetailTouchPoints.com: Your survey found that 56% of consumers are most comfortable using AI for support and recommendations, while 31% would let AI make lower-stakes decisions such as selecting products on their own. What does that split mean for retailers investing in AI shopping assistants and agentic commerce?

Cayla Curtis: The opportunity is there, but retailers need to recognize that consumers see a meaningful difference between AI helping them make a decision and AI making that decision for them. Ping’s research found that consumer comfort levels drop as AI moves from providing support and recommendations to taking action.

For retailers, the near-term sweet spot is using AI to remove friction by comparing products, narrowing choices, offering relevant recommendations, and preparing transactions, while keeping the consumer in control of the final decision. As shoppers become more comfortable delegating routine tasks, retailers can expand those capabilities, but autonomy should be earned rather than assumed. Consumers need to understand what an agent can do, what information it can access, and when it will come back to them for approval.

RetailTouchPoints.com: Respondents set an average limit of $200 for routine purchases an AI agent can make without approval, yet 42% cap that limit at $100 or less and 22% won’t trust AI with any financial transaction. How should retailers design autonomous checkout and approval steps around those limits?

Curtis: There shouldn’t be a universal threshold for autonomous checkout. The fact that consumers set such different limits tells us they want to define their own boundaries.

Retailers should give customers granular controls to decide how much an agent can spend, what types of products it can purchase, and when additional approval is required. A customer might be comfortable letting an agent automatically reorder a $30 household staple, for example, but want explicit approval for a new $300 electronics purchase. Those permissions should also be easy to review, change, or revoke. When a transaction falls outside those boundaries, the agent should seamlessly return control to the customer for approval.

How Can Retailers Build AI Shopping Agents That Reflect Customer Values?

RetailTouchPoints.com: Seventy-one percent of consumers worry that an AI agent acting for them could misrepresent their personality, ethics or values. How can retailers build shopping agents that reflect customer preferences accurately, and what’s at stake if they get it wrong?

Curtis: This finding shows that consumers are thinking about more than whether an agent will pick the wrong size or color. They’re asking whether it will accurately represent them on a deeper, more complex level.

Retailers need to give consumers visibility into the preferences an agent is using and the ability to correct, refine, or override them. If an agent repeatedly makes choices that feel inconsistent with who a customer is or what they value, that becomes a trust problem. As agents become a bigger part of the shopping journey, getting representation right will be essential to maintaining the customer relationship.

RetailTouchPoints.com: Only 33% of consumers would give an AI agent “read” access to their primary email inbox, even if it saved them five hours of admin work a week. What does that reluctance tell retailers that depend on personal data to drive personalization?

Curtis: Convenience alone isn’t enough to justify unlimited access.

Retailers should move away from the assumption that more data automatically creates a better customer experience. AI personalization should be built around purpose-specific, minimum-necessary access that asks for the information required, explains why it is needed, and gives the consumer control over how long that permission lasts. If consumers feel they have to surrender broad access to participate in an AI-powered experience, retailers risk undermining the trust that personalization is supposed to strengthen.

RetailTouchPoints.com: More than half of consumers say knowing when AI is in use matters more than getting the fastest result, and 20% would leave a website immediately if they suspected undisclosed AI. How should retailers disclose AI use without adding friction, and should that approach change by market?

Curtis: Transparency doesn’t have to mean adding another page of fine print or a disruptive pop-up to every interaction. It can be as simple as a clear disclosure that tells the customer when they are interacting with AI, what role it is playing, and when an action requires their approval. Consumers also told us trustworthy AI should explain recommendations and provide a clear path to a human when necessary.

Retailers should also absolutely consider regional differences. 63% of consumers in the U.S. and 68% in Australia prioritize knowing when AI is being used, while 62% of consumers in Indonesia prioritize speed and accuracy over disclosure. The underlying principle of transparency should remain consistent, but how retailers deliver that transparency can reflect local expectations.

How Can Retailers Rebuild Trust While Asking for More Customer Data?

RetailTouchPoints.com: Only 12% of consumers fully trust organizations to manage their identity data, down from 17% last year. What steps can retailers take to rebuild that trust while asking shoppers for more data to power AI experiences?

Curtis: Retailers need to be careful about assuming consumers will exchange more data for more AI-powered convenience. Every new request for access has to come with a clear value proposition and clear boundaries. That starts with collecting only what is necessary, being transparent about how it will be used, and giving consumers meaningful control over permissions.

As AI agents become central to e-commerce, retailers also need to distinguish between the customer and the agent acting on that customer’s behalf. They need to know who or what is acting, whether that agent is legitimately connected to the customer, and what it has actually been authorized to do. Trust will come from giving consumers more visibility and control over their identity and data, not simply asking them to trust that those systems are working as intended.

RetailTouchPoints.com: Three in four consumers say government regulation that protects data in AI applications is important. How should retailers prepare for new rules, and what can they do now to get ahead of them?

Curtis: Retailers shouldn’t wait for regulation to define the minimum acceptable standard. Instead, they should commit to building AI experiences around consumer control from the start. Businesses should be able to verify when an agent is legitimately acting for a customer and ensure its actions stay within the authority that customer has granted. They also need a clear record of those actions so they can demonstrate accountability. Regulations will continue to evolve, but retailers that make trust and control part of the infrastructure now will be better positioned to adapt as new requirements emerge.

Related stories:

Retail Trendcaster Webinar Series
Retail Strategy & Planning Series
Holiday ThinkTank