5 Ways Small Businesses Can Make Holiday Packages More Memorable

Published: November 20, 2026

Consider a customer who discovers your business online while holiday shopping. They may spend twenty minutes comparing some products, reading about your story, and placing their first order. A few days later, a plain brown box arrives on their porch containing the product and a packing slip. The product itself is excellent, but the experience of receiving it is indistinguishable from every other package delivered that week.

Small businesses can benefit from giving special attention to packaging, particularly during the fourth quarter. Holiday shoppers are often first-time buyers, prompted by a recommendation, a gift guide, or a search result. The package is the first physical object that business places in the customer’s hands, and it arrives at the only point in the transaction where a brand has the customer’s full attention and final evaluation.. Making your package memorable provides an unspoken advantage.

Most small businesses treat packaging as a line item in shipping costs, but approached deliberately, it functions as a marketing channel the customer has already agreed to receive. Here is where and why that investment pays off.

Begin with the Exterior

The outside of the box does the most work, which makes it one of the easiest ways for a small business to showcase their brand this season. It is what the customer sees on the doorstep, what sits on the kitchen counter while they find scissors, and what appears in the background if they photograph the contents.

Improving it does not require a massive (or expensive) overhaul. A branded sticker sealing a plain mailer accomplishes most of what a printed box does at a fraction of the cost. Custom packing tape delivers similar consistency on every order without requiring a significant volume commitment. For businesses that do invest in printed mailers, the more practical approach is to order one or two sizes used most often rather than a full range that will sit in storage until spring.

Treat the Interior as Part of the Product

Opening a box to find a product loose among packing peanuts communicates to a customer that presentation doesn’t matter, their order was one of many hastily packed and shipped. On the other hand, opening a package to find the product gift-wrapped in tissue paper and sealed with a sticker shows thoughtfulness and taste, and the cost difference is measured in cents per order.

Tissue paper, crinkle fill in a brand color, or a simple wrap-and-seal treatment introduces a brief pause between opening the box and reaching the product. That pause is the entire mechanism at work. It signals that someone considered and hand-wrapped this particular order, which remains one of the clearest distinctions and advantages between a small business and a fulfillment warehouse.

Add a Personal Signature Where it Counts

The most effective insert available to most small businesses costs nothing but time: a brief handwritten note.

It does not need to be long, and it should not be a form letter reproduced by hand. One or two lines referencing the specific order, the color selected, the likelihood that it is a gift, or the hope that it arrives on schedule or that the customer likes it, contributes more to customer retention than a comparable spend on acquisition.

Holiday volume can make this difficult to sustain across every order, and that constraint is worth planning around rather than abandoning the practice altogether. Reserving handwritten notes for first-time customers or for orders above a set value preserves most of the effect at a manageable workload. Where handwriting is genuinely impractical, printed note cards carrying a signature and a single handwritten line perform nearly just as well.

Give Every Package a Second Purpose

Each box shipped represents a delivery vehicle already paid for. Most businesses will send it out carrying nothing beyond the product itself.

A little something extra changes that calculation. Including a discount code redeemable in January is the familiar version, and it works precisely because it reaches the customer at the moment they are most favorably disposed toward the business. Other options are worth considering as well: a referral card the recipient can pass along, care instructions that reduce return rates, a percent off their next order, a QR code linking to a gift guide or exchange form, or a brief card explaining the business’s mission and values.

That final example carries more weight than it initially appears to. During the holidays, a substantial share of the people opening a business’s packages are not its customers. They are people its customers care about. Introducing the brand to that audience costs one printed card and reaches them at a moment of genuine goodwill.

Design the Set, Not the Pieces

The four tactics above are worth considerably more in combination than in isolation, and only when they share a cohesive visual language.

The discipline here mirrors what applies to storefront signage and direct mail: one color palette, one typeface pairing, one simple motif, applied consistently across every element. The sticker, the tissue paper, the note card, and the insert should read as a coordinated set. When they do, a customer ordering again in March recognizes the package before reading the label. When they do not, the packaging reads as an assortment of unrelated promotional purchases, which leaves a weaker impression than a plain box would have.

Achieving this does not require a design budget or outside help. It requires selecting a palette and a motif once, documenting them, and holding to those choices when the next order goes in during the November rush.

Measure Packaging Against the Next Order

There is a natural tendency to evaluate packaging against the transaction it accompanies, where it registers as pure expense. The return does not appear on that line. It appears in January, when a customer who received something that left an impression returns to the site directly instead of browsing competitors’ offerings.

Holiday volume represents the single moment in the year when a small business introduces itself to a large number of people simultaneously, most of whom may never encounter its advertising. What arrives on their doorstep is that introduction. A few dollars and some advance planning determine resonance and repeat purchases.

Erin Shea is the Senior Director of North America Marketing at VistaPrint. VistaPrint helps small business owners and entrepreneurs create custom designs and professional marketing.

 

 

Related stories:

Retail Trendcaster Webinar Series
Retail Strategy & Planning Series
Holiday ThinkTank