Retail Media’s NASCAR Problem Is Costing Retailers Holiday Revenue

Published: November 17, 2026

Every holiday season, retailers face enormous pressure to squeeze more revenue out of the gifting-driven surge in their web traffic.

This creates an obvious temptation: Advertisers want more exposure, shoppers are spending more time on the site, why not create more places to advertise? The problem is that eventually the store starts to look like a NASCAR stock car, with logos covering every available inch until you can barely see what is underneath.

A lot of retail sites are starting to approach advertising in much the same way.

Why More Ad Placements Can Hurt the Shopping Experience

Incremental sponsored placements can make money for the retailer without actually providing value to the shopper. If someone repeatedly sees sponsored products that have little to do with what they are actually looking for, they grow suspicious of anything labeled “Sponsored,” and eventually learn to ignore them.

This becomes especially important during the holidays because discovery is such a big part of how people shop. Someone might arrive knowing they need a gift for a teenager, a new television for the family or a toy for a niece or nephew without knowing the exact product they want.

Holiday Discovery Depends on Relevance, Not Volume

A sponsored product that introduces someone to an item they want to buy is doing its job: the shopper finds something useful, the advertiser gets a sale and the retailer makes advertising revenue.

Amazon is an example of this cycle at work. The retail giant has built advertising deeply into the shopping experience, with sponsored products appearing across search, browse and product pages, all designed around what someone is searching for or likely to buy. This relevance is what lets advertising natively become part of discovery.

The mistake other retailers make is copying the number of ads Amazon shows without first getting the relevance right.

Part of the reason for this imbalance is that most retail media systems make ad density easy and relevance hard. Many historically ranked ads primarily by keyword match and bid, so the slot went to the highest bidder whether or not that shopper was likely to buy. But relevance at scale is a prediction problem, and machine learning — trained on signals from real purchase behavior — is well-suited to address it. Retailers can now access this capability through partners rather than building it in-house.

Why Retail Media Revenue Grows When Ads Match Shopper Intent

After their first four weeks with Moloco, the majority of our retailers have at least doubled the ad revenue they earn on each dollar of merchandise sales. When ads are relevant and match what shoppers want, shoppers keep clicking and advertisers keep spending.

That is why relevance is going to matter more than ad density as retail media grows. Density executed effectively is an output of relevance. If retailers get better at predicting what someone actually wants to buy, they can show more advertising without making the experience worse.

And there is a lot of room for retailers to grow here: search results, product pages and other parts of the store serve different purposes, so the advertising should behave differently in each.

The pressure to get this right will be even higher during the holidays, when retailers are trying to capture as much revenue as possible while demand is high. There will always be another advertiser willing to pay for another placement, but retailers should be careful about taking that money if the ad makes the store worse for the person trying to shop there. Otherwise, they risk ending up with a lot of logos on the car and a shopper who has learned to tune all of them out.

Pat CopelandPat Copeland is General Manager of Moloco Commerce Media, where he leads strategy, product innovation and growth for the company’s AI-powered commerce advertising business. He brings more than 30 years of experience in machine learning, advertising and enterprise software, having held leadership roles at Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Zendesk, including helping launch and scale Amazon’s Sponsored Brands into a multibillion-dollar advertising platform.

 

Related Stories:

Retail Trendcaster Webinar Series
Retail Strategy & Planning Series
Holiday ThinkTank